Deep-Skillet Pizza with Roasted Pepper Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, and Garlic Parmesan Crust
I must give high credit to my inspirer in the instance of skillet pizza.. this recipe is adapted from one originally posted by Nick over at Macheesmo.com, and a link to his version can be found here. I was very happy to find a simplistic pizza recipe, as pizza has been my reigning favorite since like, first grade. (Perhaps it is the nostalgia of Pizza Fridays, or my grandmother’s history as a pizza store owner [Pizza Villa, Meadeville, PA] … but more likely just my obsession with cheese continuing into adult life.) Either way! This recipe is AWESOME, and I learned a little something about baking flour as well. ahem:
Pizza dough calls for Bread Flour– perhaps I am still new at this, but I wasn’t terribly sure what the difference was from All-Purpose White. Checking into it– Bread Flour has a higher gluten content, which makes for the extra elasticity that is oh-so-important for pizza! I’ve certainly handled frozen pizza doughs in the past, so that made a lot of sense to me. I ended up having a bit of difficulty rolling the dough into a pretty little round shape, since it does tend to fight you a little to stay in place. I ended up essentially just smushing it into a pizza crust shape– and wouldn’t have known the difference! Although I will say that in the post I was eying over while making this, Nick makes one hell of a pretty shape with his crust– well done sir. I also impulsively decided to coat my crust with a dusting of garlic powder, and fairly generous sprinkling of grated Parmesan cheese. This final step, friends, was purely fast-food-driven at heart– my favorite part of a Domino’s pizza!
Sidenote #1: In my world, there exists such a thing as McDinner. This is where I make McDonald’s dinner from scratch: burgers (ketchup, orange cheese, + pickle slices– no lettuce or mustard! ew to onions, generally speaking), chicken nuggets, salted shoestring fries, a chilled Coca Cola, + often a milkshake. But so much less guilt! Sort of! … And yes, I am a breed of 26-year-old 8-year-old, if you had to know.
Deep Skillet Pizza with Roasted Pepper Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, and Garlic-Parmesan Crust
For Pizza Dough
- 2 1/2 c. bread flour
- 1 Tb. white sugar
- 2 tsp. salt
- 3/4 tsp. active dry yeast
- 1 c. warm water
- olive oil to coat
For Sauce
- 4 cloves minced garlic
- 7 oz. jar, roasted red peppers, chopped
- 1 15 oz. can plain tomato sauce
- 2 tsp. ground oregano
- 2 lg. pinches, crushed red pepper
- 2 tsp. dried basil + sprinkle on top
- salt, pepper, olive oil
To Finish Pie
- 12″ Iron Skillet (of course)
- 8 oz ball of fresh mozzarella cheese (or 8-10 oz of your choice)
- garlic powder
- parmesan cheese
Making The Dough takes no less than 4 hours– and that is when you can start assembling the pizza. You can definitely feel free to make the dough ahead of time, and if you make extra– you can freeze it and keep it on hand for easy pizza making! Mix yeast, sugar, salt, + warm water in a large bowl. Allow to sit for approximately 5 minutes, until the yeast looks a little fizzy, and the water has become cloudy. Add in the flour. Using clean hands, blend the flour into the liquid until it begins forming into a ball of dough. Continue kneading for 5-10 minutes, and add tiny (tiny!) increments of warm water if the dough is not reaching the stretchy, soft consistency that it should within a couple of minutes. You should be left with a nice ball of dough.

Coat the ball with generous layer of olive oil and place in a large ziplock bag. Seal + let it sit at room temperature for about an hour. Supposedly, you need to take it out of the ziplock at this point to “degas” it.. but my dough wasn’t all that gassy. Rebag the dough and move to refrigerator, where it should be allowed to chill for at least 2 hours (can be left for longer, if you make it before work, etc!). Remove the dough at least one hour prior to making the ‘za, so it has an additional hour to rise at room temperature.
Making The Sauce is something I began around this time– the final hour of waiting for the dough to be ready. This is where we should all get a little creative! While the following ingredients are what I chose (cabinet hunting), you are welcome to improvise the sauce obviously. I would not recommend buying pizza sauce though, because that’s like. No fun.
For The Sauce I Made: Begin with a capful of olive oil in the bottom of a medium saucepan, and heat. Add the minced garlic, and allow to brown but keep it moving. Drain the jar of roasted peppers most of the way, and add them in (I ended up chopping them with the end of a plastic spatula, because they’re super soft, so I found no need to prepare them ahead of time. I also added in a bit of the juice, to help flavor the sauce!) Cook peppers until they’re sizzling hot, 7 minutes or so.
Add in the can of sauce + seasonings, and bring to a simmer. I would highly recommend keeping a splatter guard/cover on hand, for in between stirs. Tomato sauce has a tendency to really want to jump out of the pot, as I’m sure many of you know! I also used this waiting time to slice up the ball of cheese into the thinnest pieces I could manage, and to finish up an intense game of scrabble (and only lost by 27 points).
Assembling The Pizza: Preheat the oven to 450°. Once the dough is ready, roll it with a pin (as much as possible) into a shape that will be a bit larger than your iron skillet. Most skillets will be “conditioned” and in no need of extra stick resistance, but since mine is brand new– I sprayed it with a bit of Olive Oil cooking spray, and rubbed that in with a bit of paper towel. I ended up sort of… plopping the rolled out dough somewhere in the middle, and stretching it by hand, rolling over the edges upon themselves into the shape of pizza crust. The importance lies in creating an even layer of dough throughout the bottom surface. Then, I added an introductory layer of parmesan cheese + garlic powder.. not too much though.. with a focus especially on the edges/crust.
If I could go back and redo this again, I’d likely add a little less sauce than I ended up using. It was totally delicious, but did get a little messy(ier than even I have an appreciation for). I am also a fan of the cheese > sauce ratio. So yes. Continuing on.. Sauce it, spread on the layer of cheese. I added a bit more sauce on top, as well, and a sprinkling of basil.
Cooking The Pizza: Now that the pizza is ready to be cooked, begin by heating the skillet over a high range, for approximately 3 minutes. The bottom of the pie may begin to golden, but more importantly — the pan will become very hot, an important part of proper pizza making (so I’ve learned from this recipe!). Then, move to the oven, allow to bake for approximately 15 minutes before checking. Leave it in for longer for a crunchier crust!
I finished my pie off with another layer of parmesan around the edge, of course. Move from the skillet to a wooden cutting board or other location for the pizza to cool off for a while. While the final stretch of waiting will be torturous, my friends in food– it is also a great time to take almost 50 photos of your finished pizza. That’s totally normal… right?













